

The City of Bethlehem in 1954 was growing into what was then called the "Great Northwest", as new housing was under construction throughout the area known as Hanover and Schoenersville straddling the newly opened superhighway named Route 22. Companies such as Bethlehem Steel and Western Electric were attracting new employees and their families to the area.
In response to the need to provide new facilities for religious worship for the increasing number of Catholic families, the Archdiocese of Philadelphia, on February 11, 1954, authorized the establishment of a new parish to be located at Catasauqua and Kelchner Roads in Bethlehem, Pennsylvania. The site was a fiveacre plot of land, part of the Werner estate, containing only a farmhouse and an old dairy barn. Since 1954 was a Marian year, the new parish was named Notre Dame of Bethlehem, Notre Dame meaning Our Lady. Appropriately, it was founded on the feast of Our Lady of Lourdes. Archbishop John F. O'Hara, C.S.C. appointed Rev. Thomas J. Doyle as Notre Dame's first pastor.

Fr. Doyle then visited and enlisted the aid of future members of the newly named parish and a contract was awarded to remodel the barn. The remodeled barn served as a temporary church while a refurbished farmhouse served as a temporary rectory. Two months later on Passion Sunday, April 4, 1954, the first Mass was celebrated by Fr. Doyle in the first church which seated 350. By June 1954, 280 families had been registered and by September 1955, the registered families had increased to 430 families, an increase of over 50% in fifteen months.

Noting the need for schools, an elementary school was the first building project which began in September 26, 1954. The Sisters of Saint Joseph of Chestnut Hill were asked to staff the school and provisions were made by including a convent in the building project. Among the fund raisers was the first carnival held on August 18 21, 1954 in a rainstorm. Nevertheless, it was a social and financial success. The new school was dedicated by Archbishop O'Hara on September 25, 1955 with Sister Joseph Daniel serving as its first PRINCIPAL for a student population that numbered 240. By 1956, enrollment had risen to 320. The teaching faculty of SSJ nuns were temporarily housed at 1905 Catasauqua Road.

The old farmhouse which served as the rectory had to be demolished to make way for the widening of Catasauqua Road. A new (current) rectory was built and completed on September 12, 1956.
By 1957, 600 families belonged to the parish and the school enrollment had risen to 400. It was decided to add a second floor to the school in the summer of 1957.

The convent building was begun in August 1958, and occupied on April,1959.

In 1958, a shrine to the Blessed Virgin Mary, under whose patronage the parish was founded, was built by the men of the parish and dedicated. On July 1960, ground breaking for a new church was held and the first Sunday Mass was celebrated on June 25, 1961.
In February 1961, the Allentown Diocese was formed with Joseph McShea appointed by Pope John XXIII as its first bishop.
In 1962, Pope John convened the Second Vatican Council which eventually ushered in many liturgical changes.

In 1963, Father Doyle was elevated to Domestic Prelate, with the title of Reverend Monsignor and was among the first group of priests to be so honored in the newly established Allentown Diocese.
The renovation of the main altar allowing celebrants to face the people was completed in 1969. By April 1970, the new order of the Mass began at Notre Dame.
A significant occasion in the parish history occurred when the $565,000.00 mortgage was declared paid on October 12, 1971. The occasion was marked by a ceremonial mortgage burning held in the parish Church Hall in November.

In October 18, 1975, a new shrine in honor of Our Lady was dedicated and located in the vestibule of the church and the Baptistry was relocated to the Sanctuary.
The 25th year was marked with celebrations on February 8 11, 1979. When Msgr. Doyle retired in 1984, Bishop Thomas J. Welsh, second bishop of the Allentown Diocese, appointed Rev. Frederick J. Loeper as the second pastor of Notre Dame. For the 40th anniversary celebration of the parish, a capital campaign gave rise to an annex in the school and the renovation of the Church. Unfortunately, Fr. Loeper was called by our Maker the day after his 68th birthday on August 31, 1996. With Fr. Loeper’s passing, Bishop Welsh appointed Rev. Msgr. Joseph E. Kurtz as the third pastor of Notre Dame. On October 1997, the new annex of the school was dedicated in honor of Fr. Loeper.
In 1999, then Msgr. Kurtz was ordained bishop of Knoxville, Tennessee. Bishop Edward Cullen, third bishop of Allentown, appointed Rev. Msgr. William E. Handges as the fourth pastor of Notre Dame. On September 3, 2000, a statue of Jesus with Children was dedicated by Msgr. Richard E. Loeper, Bishop Kurtz, and and Msgr. Handges in remembrance of Fr. Loeper.
In June 2005, Bishop Cullen appointed Rev. Msgr. Thomas J. Benestad as the fifth pastor of Notre Dame. In February 2007, Msgr. Benestad went on a medical leave and in March 2007, Bishop Cullen appointed Rev. Thomas D. Baddick as administrator and eventually the sixth pastor of Notre Dame.

![]()
| Notre Dame of Bethlehem Parish | ||
|---|---|---|
| PASTORS | ||
| 1954 1984 | | Rev. Msgr. Thomas J. Doyle |
| 1984 19960831 | | Rev. Frederick J. Loeper |
| 1996 1999 |
Rev. Msgr. Joseph E. Kurtz (Bishop in 19991208; Archbishop in 20070815 ) |
|
| 1999 2005 | Rev. Msgr. William E. Handges | |
| 2005 2007 | Rev. Msgr. Thomas J. Benestad | |
| 2007 present | Rev. Msgr. Thomas D. Baddick | |
| ASSISTANT PASTORS | ||
| 1958 1961 | Rev. Edward W. McElduff | |
| 1961 1965 | | Rev. Msgr. James J. McHale |
| 1962 1969 | | Rev. William H. Mooney |
| 1965 1968 | Rev. Msgr. Thomas E. Hoban | |
| 1965 1969 | Rev. Francis T. Gillespie | |
| 1969 1970 | Rev. Robert J. Potts | |
| 1969 1970 | | Rev. James J. Agosta |
| 1970 1971 | | Rev. Thomas M. Courtney |
| 1970 1971 | Rev. Leo F. Lenick | |
| 1971 1975 | Rev. Edward G. Ganster | |
| 1971 1972 | Rev. Richard C. Mushorn | |
| 1973 1975 | Rev. Steven J. Safko | |
| 1975 | | Rev. William H. Carter |
| 1975 1976 | Rev. John J. Denburger | |
| 1976 1977 | | Rev. John G. Pasura |
| 1976 1979 | Rev. Joseph A. Lukach | |
| 1978 1979 | Rev. William J. Nahn | |
| 1978 | Rev. Joseph Allan | |
| 1979 1989 | Rev. James J. Morgan | |
| 1979 1980 | Rev. Joseph J. Campion | |
| 1980 1983 | Rev. Stephen J. Radocha | |
| 1981 1983 | Rev. Robert J. McConaghy | |
| 1982 1983 | Rev. Francis P. Schoenauer | |
| 1983 1991 | Rev. David W. Karns | |
| 1985 1987 | Rev. William P. Jones | |
| 1989 1993 | Rev. John A. Frink | |
| 1991 1992 | Rev. Eric J. Gruber | |
| 1992 1995 | Rev. Richard Brensinger | |
| 1993 1996 | Rev. Thomas D. Baddick | |
| 1995 1997 | Rev. Richard W. Campo | |
| 1996 2000 | Rev. Paul Rothermel | |
| 1997 2001 | Rev. Gregory R. Karpyn | |
| 2000 2003 | Rev. Joseph D. Hulko | |
| 2003 2004 | Rev. Edward J. Essig | |
| 2004 current | Rev. Joel E. Kiefer | |
| IN RESIDENCE | ||
| 1954 1963 | Rev. Henry E. Strassner | |
| ? | Rev. John J. Duminiak | |
| ? | Rev. Paul L. Bader | |
| ? | Rev. Robert R. Fagan | |
| ? | Rev. Msgr. John A. Rusak | |
| ? | Rev. Walter T. Schaeffer | |
| ? current | Rev. Bernard J. Ezaki | |
| 2000 2005 | Rev. Msgr. John A. Auchter | |
| 2005 current | Rev. Achilles O. Ayaton | |
| PERMANENT DEACONS | ||
| 1982 20010908 | | Mr. Lemuel B. von Leer |
| 19950520 20080111 | | Mr. Richard T. Sewald, Sr. |
| 20060520 current | Dr. Hugh M. Carlin | |
| Notre Dame Elementary School | ||
| Date of Arrival | SISTERS OF SAINT JOSEPH | |
| 1955 |
Sr. Joseph Daniel Monaghan (PRINCIPAL)
Sr. Gabriel Marie MacDonald Sr. Anne Dennis Mara Sr. Edward Annice Quigley |
|
| 1956 |
Sr. Alma Loretto Murphy
Sr. Grace Eileen Forker |
|
| 1957 | Sr. Regina Meehan (S. Martin Maureen) | |
| 1958 |
Sr. Regina Immacular Monaghan
Sr. Katharine Doyle (S. Maureen de Lourdes) |
|
| 1959 |
Sr. Catherine O'Brien (S. George Aloysius)
Sr. Consolata Maria Dunleavy Sr. Ann Massarelli (S. John Joseph) |
|
| 1960 |
Sr. Catherine Bernard Lowe
Sr. Caroline Pout Sr. Anne Towey (S. Clare Isabelle) Sr. Rose Edward Carlin Sr. Patrick Francis McCormack |
|
| 1961 |
Sr. Regina Angela Lawler (PRINCIPAL)
Sr. Rose Lorena Reilly Sr. Ellen Murphy (S. Ellen Cornelius) Sr. Rita Marian Connell Sr. Dorothy Patricia Quinn |
|
| 1962 |
Sr. Clare Regina Cramsey
Sr. Ellen McCarthy (S. Thomas Maureen) Sr. Marion Francis Sr. Therese Margarite McFadden |
|
| 1963 |
Sr. Alice Elizabeth Moran
Sr. Saint Hilda Clark Sr. Elizabeth Mercer (S. Mary Claude) Sr. Agnes Genevieve Kelm Sr. MIriam Carmelita Romanelli Sr. Regina Smith (S. Regina Raphael) |
|
| 1964 |
Sr. Mary Patricia Gorman (S. Charles Joseph)
Sr. Kathryn F. McTague (S. Edward Anglea) |
|
| 1965 |
Sr. Mary Philip Robinson
Sr. Elizabeth Ann O'Donnell (S. Helena) Sr. Marcia Ann Gehman (S. Marion William) Sr. Elizabeth Tombler (S. Marie Eulalia) |
|
| 1966 |
Sr. Therese Gertrude Dougherty
Sr. Marian Agnes Pearson Sr. Catherine T. Henry (S. Joseph Catherine) |
|
| 1967 |
Sr. Ruth M. Snyder (S. Ann Agnes PRINCIPAL)
Sr. Dolores C. Byrne (S. Catherine Edward) Dr. Dolores Burkhardt (S. Stella Joseph) Sr. Mary Esther Lee (S. Dorothy Therese) |
|
| 1968 |
Sr. Mary Theresa Holmes (S. Margaret Fidelis)
Sr. Miriam James McGovern Sr. Veronica Mary Batley (S. Dorothy Joseph) Sr. Veronica Anne Kaiser (S. Alice Veronica) Sr. Berenice Adams Sr. Diana H. Cerchio (S. Charles Christopher) Sr. Rita Therese Kehoe Sr. Christine Marie Farrell |
|
| 1969 |
Sr. William Stanislaus White (PRINCIPAL)
Sr. Josephine Marie Tray (S. Mary Maud) |
|
| 1970 | Sr. Karen Marie Doyle (S. Denise Anne) | |
| 1971 |
Sr. Anne Patricia Meyers (S. Patrick Christine)
Sr. Roseanne Orchon (S. Joseph Rosemary) Sr. Elizabeth Bowden (S. William Kathleen) |
|
| 1972 |
Sr. Patricia Ann Brennan (S. Robert Loretta)
Sr. Marie Francine O'Brien (S. Gerald Francine) Sr. Mary Ursula Lockhart |
|
| 1973 | Sr. Diana Stone (S. Florence Peter) | |
| 1974 |
Sr. Angela Hemler (S. Miriam Angela PRINCIPAL)
Sr. Roberta Hoolahan (S. Roberta) Sr. Ann Marie Crowley (S. WIlliam Annice) Sr. Paul Christin van Thuyme |
|
| 1976 |
Sr. Leah M. Jones (S. Mary Eunice)
Sr. Deborah Lyn Miller Sr. Alma Patricia Giles |
|
| 1977 |
Sr. Regina Consuela Kropp
Sr. Maria Bernadette Zakreski |
|
| 1978 | Sr. Marianne C. Whelan (S. Mary Isabella) | |
| 1979 |
Sr. Mary Hugh Murphy
Sr. Loretta Kathleen McGuckin Sr. Karen Anderson |
|
| 1980 |
Sr. Saint Esther Ryan
Sr. Dorothy Wilkinson (S. Vincent Martha) |
|
| 1981 | Sr. Helen Madara (S. Mary Palma) | |
| 1982 |
Sr. Mary Adalbert Chiswalk
Sr. Mary of the Nativity McNamara Sr. Ann Sweeney (S. Regina Muriel) Sr. Marie Patricia O'Hagan |
|
| 1984 | Sr. Audrey Butler (S. Saint Madeline) | |
| 1986 |
Sr. Carol Ann Polack (S. Laura Edward PRINCIPAL)
Sr. Mary O'Donnell (S. Michael Raymond) |
|
| 1987 |
Sr. Eileen Kean (S. Thomas Dorothy)
Sr. Mary Elizabeth Guyer (S. Margaret Eugenie PRINCIPAL) |
|
| 1988 |
Sr. William Cecelia Whelan
Sr. Ann Walter McAllister Sr. Rita Miriam McDonald Sr. Marie Lawrence Robinson |
|
| 1990 |
Sr. Patricia Cullen (S. Joseph Raphael PRINCIPAL)
Sr. Anita Joseph Wagner |
|
| 1992 | Sr. Virginia Stephanie Bator | |
| 1993 |
Sr. Marie Saint Mark McGrillis
Sr. Mary Agnes Foy |
|
| 1994 | Sr. Marion A. Pfaff (S. Adelina) | |
| LAY PRINCIPAL | ||
| ? 2006 | Mrs. Christine Schwab | |
| 2006 current | Mrs. Kathy Maziarz | |
| Notre Dame Convent | ||
| Sisters of Saint Joseph IN RESIDENCE | ||
| 1976 | Sr. Alma Patricia Giles | |
| 1978 | Sr. Marianne D. Whelan | |
| 1979 |
Sr. Cecile Anne Reiley
Sr. Rosemarie Lorenz |
|
| 1980 | Sr. Mary Elizabeth Kendall | |
| 1982 |
Sr. Catherine Loyola Tasker
Sr. Marie Bernadette Conley Sr. Marie Adelbert Chiswalk |
|
| 1984 | Sr. Mary McCarron | |
| 1985 | Sr. Mary Louise Piccone | |
| 1988 |
Sr. Francis Celine Bennett
Sr. Marie Saint Mark McGrillis Sr. Saint Urban O'Donnell Sr. Mary Esdras Allwein Sr. Anne B. Towey |
|
| 1993 |
Sr. Mary Audrey O'Connor
Sr. Francis Dolores Meyers |
|
| 1995 |
Sr. Frances Bernadette Dolan
Sr. Eleanor Mary Bringenberg Sr. John Bernard Gallagher |
|
| 1996 |
Sr. Elizabeth Agnes Zubaly
Sr. Agnes Mary Foy |
|
| 1997 |
Sr. Alice Loretto Brennan
Sr. Elizabeth Ochs |
|
| 2000 | Sr. Mary Audrey O'Connor | |
| 2001 |
Sr. Eleanor Therese Day
Sr. Jane Day Sr. Marion L. Steiner |
|
| 2002 |
Sr. Agnes Leona Arnold
Sr. Saint Urban O'Donnell |
|
| June 2008 closing of the convent | ||

![]()